Back to Discussions
Help

To what extent is the regulation of AI-generated images possible?

NNJ
Translated to English·

I understand that regulations on AI-generated images are becoming stricter, but where is the line drawn for what is acceptable in terms of order? I believe that discipline and rules are necessary, and I am aware that there are various issues such as exposure, copyright, and dignity. However, I am looking for clear-cut answers, such as "this cannot be visible" or "commercial proper nouns are prohibited."

7 replies

香音·

I often think this too. Precisely because it's AI, I want to try things that aren't possible, but regulations are important after all. Still, breasts are now all over the internet regardless of public morals. I wonder how it will turn out.

I suspect that, regardless of AI, the problem might be a system that displays content that can get a site sued and shut down by its funding sources, such as advertisers or credit card companies. You need the pretense of having regulation filters for sensitive content, I think. Maybe!

N
NJOP·

It's a pretext that there are regulation filters, isn't it? It must be tough to go through all that just to enjoy it by yourself.

J
Jun·

It’s a bit startling when a piece of creative work that seems perfectly fine gets flagged with "The image may contain sensitive content, so it cannot be displayed."

S
SNoW·

I understand your frustration. The way blocking and display currently work may indeed be a bit rough around the edges, and we are working on improving those aspects bit by bit.

I completely understand your feeling of "I just want to enjoy this by myself." However, please let me clarify one thing. This site is more like a public square in a city than a toy you play with at home. This is especially true since it’s a free site that doesn't even require a login. Furthermore, because users from multiple countries visit, that "square" becomes even broader.

Therefore, there are inevitably things that might be okay to play with at home but change when you bring them into a public square.

As for the specific rules:
・All photorealistic Sensitive Content is prohibited.
・Sensitive Content involving characters that clearly appear to be minors, whether anime or photorealistic, is strictly prohibited.
・Anime-style R18 content cannot be generated. R15 content can be generated, but it cannot currently be posted to the Gallery.

Since these rules are a combination of regulations from multiple countries, they might seem a bit strict.

However, even though these are the rules, the actual judgment relies heavily on automated AI detection, so things that should be prohibited sometimes get through, and conversely, images that shouldn't be a problem sometimes get blocked. We are fine-tuning this as well, and our goal remains in line with the rules mentioned above.

N
NJOP·

Thank you for your very clear explanation. I understand now.

J
Jun·

Is it a regulation? I imagine you're going through a lot, SNoW. It would be nice if there were a way to rewrite the note on the image to say "This is AI" or something like that.

Leave a reply

Join the community to share your thoughts and ideas.

Sign in to join the discussion